Since opening its doors in West Orange, New Jersey, Johnny’s Pizzeria has become a neighborhood favorite for authentic Italian food made with care and quality ingredients. Conveniently located on Main Street, near West Orange Municipal Building and Town Hall. This family-owned restaurant is known for its New York–style pizza, hearty pasta dishes, and signature Italian subs. Whether dining in, picking up, or ordering delivery, Johnny’s Pizzeria continues to be a cornerstone of great food and friendly service throughout Essex County, NJ.
Customer Reviews (According to Google Reviews)
Michael H. said,
“Very friendly staff! Every item on the menu is delicious! They are always reliable for great pizza, pasta, and sandwiches!”
According to his 5-star Google review, he rated Johnny’s Pizzeria in West Orange, NJ with Food: 5/5, Service: 5/5, and Atmosphere: 5/5.
Michael also mentioned his go-to favorites such as cheesesteaks, mozzarella sticks, buffalo wings, pasta fagioli, and Johnny’s Special.
Patrick P., a local Google reviewer, commented,
“Best cheesesteaks in West Orange! Pizza is delicious too. Very fast delivery and very friendly staff.”
Patrick rated Johnny’s Pizzeria with Food: 5/5 and Service: 5/5, emphasizing how quick and consistent the service always is.
He also recommended local favorites like classic cheese pizza, cheesesteak subs, and buffalo wings.
Mike R. noted in his Google review,
“When I worked in Orange, I would order from Johnny’s 2–3 times a week. Always fast delivery and great food. Zero complaints.”
Mike rated Johnny’s with Food: 5/5 and Service: 5/5, highlighting the friendly team and reliable delivery experience.
He mentioned popular menu choices like pepperoni pizza slice, meatball sub, and Johnny’s Special.
From loyal regulars to first-time guests, customers across Essex County, NJ consistently praise Johnny’s Pizzeria and Restaurant for its welcoming staff, quick service, and unbeatable Classic Italian Dishes. With its long-standing reputation for generous portions, quality ingredients, and local charm, Johnny’s remains a top choice for Italian cuisine in West Orange, NJ. Whether you’re craving a classic slice, a hearty sub, or a comforting bowl of pasta, this neighborhood favorite continues to serve up the authentic taste that locals love year after year.
Good news, Johnny’s Pizzeria in West Orange, NJ now has online ordering website. This saves customers money because Johnny’s does not have to pay a percentage fee for every transaction.
Visit Johnny’s Pizzeria West Orange, NJ Today
Website: johnnypizzeria.com
Location: 34 Main St, West Orange, NJ 07052
Contact: 973-731-9505